concept
Performative legitimacy
Performative legitimacy names authority maintained through visible compliance and ritualized participation rather than belief or justification. Visible compliance matters more than belief or coherence, ritual affirmation substitutes for justification, private skepticism coexists with public performance, and silence signals uncertainty while compliance signals safety. Understanding retreats to spaces where it cannot be spoken. Show trials turn confession into visible compliance, orchestrated demonstrations and unanimous votes mark legitimacy, revolutionary suicide rehearsals frame loyalty as public display. Where is legitimacy enacted rather than negotiated? What performance is required for safety in public space? Does private understanding alter standing at all? Each performance increases cost of visible dissent, collective practices substitute for shared evaluation, and official narratives frame repression as defense. The failure mode—legitimacy maintained through performance under threat alone, interpretation survives only where it cannot influence consequence. The restoration path—restore evaluative agreement as condition of standing where possible, reduce cost of non-performance before preference falsification locks in, protect domains where performance is not required for standing.
